Perfect Is Costing Your Nonprofit MoneY

Perfect Is Costing Your Nonprofit MoneY

Hi, my name is Jessica, and I'm a recovering perfectionist. In my past, I have rewritten the same subject line eleven times before letting it see daylight.

Sound familiar?

If you work in fundraising, especially if you're newer to the field, you know this trap well. You draft an appeal. You read it again. You tweak a word. You show it to a coworker. You tweak two more words. Days pass. Then a week. The appeal is still sitting in your drafts folder, waiting for a version of itself that will never exist: the perfect version.

Here's the truth nobody tells you: perfect copy stuck in revisions cannot bring in a single dollar.

I want to be clear here. Caring about quality is a good thing. Your donors deserve professional, polished communication. You should absolutely check your work against your brand guidelines. You should absolutely get the donor's name right, and the program name right, and your own organization's name right (yes, that happens more than you'd think). Those are real bars, and they matter.

But once you've cleared them, ask yourself one question: would sending this cause a scandal?

Wrong name on a major gift letter? Scandal. A sentence that could be a little tighter? Not a scandal.

Once you're past the "would cause a scandal" threshold, you're not protecting your organization anymore. You're protecting your own fear of being judged. And that fear is expensive.

Think of it like a report card. You don't need a valedictorian appeal with a perfect 100. You need a solid B+: clear ask, correct facts, on brand, nobody's name is wrong. That's launch ready. That's revenue ready.

Copy that would earn an 85% or higher is doing far more good in your donor's inbox than it will ever do sitting in an editing queue. Get it good. Proof it well. Then send it.

Because here's what actually happens when copy sits too long: the appeal deadline creeps closer, the campaign timeline gets tighter, and now you're rushing something out at the last minute anyway, except with way more stress and way less time to check it properly.

Perfectionism doesn't protect quality. It just delays it, and adds panic on top.

Or worse yet, you are launching something new and keep postponing the go-live date because the copy isn’t perfect yet. Don’t let this be you. B+ or better? Ship it!

​Nobody has ever unsubscribed because a sentence could have been tighter or could have had a smidge more hypothetical emotion. They unsubscribe because they never heard from you at all.

So, here's your assignment. Go look at your drafts folder right now. Find the appeal, the email, the letter that's been sitting there for longer than it should. Read it one more time. Check it against the real bars: is it accurate, is it on brand? Yes? Great!

Would it cause a scandal?

If not: ship it.

Your mission is waiting. Your donors are waiting. Go raise some money.

Cheers,

P.S. Want more content on fundraising and sustainable revenue growth? Subscribe to the blog and get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

subscribe today

P.P.S. If you're a nonprofit CEO or development lead who's tired of carrying the fundraising weight alone, a free discovery call is for you. Let’s chat.

Book a free discovery call here

If you liked this…

• The REAL Framework for Board Fundraising Transformation
• Things You Might Have Missed (But Really Need to Know) From the Social Impact Staff Retention Project's Latest Report
• Diversify your Fundraising Revenue: The Six Revenue Streams Every Nonprofit Needs to Truly THRIVE
• Know. Like. Trust. Give. Advocate. The Full Journey Your Board Needs to Understand
• Now. Next. Needed: The Simple Way for Nonprofit Leaders to Tell Their Story in a Way that Attracts Funding